Bob Fosse ‘wunderbar’ in MY SISTER EILEEN at retrospective 3


It came as a mild surprise even to arts·meme‘s Debra Levine, despite delivering a talk, “Bob Fosse, Dancer,” prior to the two movie musicals (both named for ladies!) screened on August 25, 2018 at UCLA Film & Television Archive’s “Fosse, Fosse, Fosse!” retrospective.

Bob Fosse was a good movie star!

First up was KISS ME KATE (MGM, 1953), the Hollywood version of the Broadway show, an uneven and lumbering film despite its marvelous Cole Porter score (including the soaring “Wunderbar“). Dance history happened when Fosse, then a contract dancer working for choreographer Hermes Pan, got the go-ahead to fashion his own duet with Carol Haney for “From This Moment On.” A choreographer was born.

Then came the discovery of the evening: how delightful, lithe, appealing, and talented a star in a major speaking role was Robert Louis Fosse, aka Bob, in MY SISTER EILEEN (1955).

The flick, a Columbia Pictures adaptation of the source material of Broadway’s “Wonderful Town,” with new (and markedly forgettable) songs by Jule Styne and Leo Robin, followed the 1942 Rosalind Russell version also made at Columbia. A cast of sincere character actors — Janet Leigh, Betty Garrett, Jack Lemon, Fosse, and Tommy Rall — populate the world of “Eileen.” And they give full throttled commitment to Fosse in his first major film-choreography credit.

The film tells of two naive Ohio sisters settling in Greenwich Village to pursue their dream careers in the big city. The horrible digs, sleazy start-up jobs, and true grit of young girls in New York rings super true. Sparse but colorful location footage adds to “Eileen”‘s period charm.


As does the girl’s best friend, Frank Lippencott, played by Mr. Fosse, not as the “soda jerk” he truly is, but as a ‘drugstore manager.’ Fosse shines in this film acting, singing, dancing … and in his easy-peasy choreography, particularly the gazebo dance (ahem, wherefore the gazebo in New York City?). His adept cast has full dancing cred, as it includes Garrett (who studied and danced with Martha Graham), Janet Leigh (who had a movie musical follow-up in Bye Bye Birdie), and the great film dancer Tommy Rall.

Film’s most renowned number in “Eileen” is the testosterone-charged “Alley Dance,” in which Fosse challenges, and to my eye, outdances the estimable Rall, making the number an illustration of the future dancing with the past.

That Fosse was in tip-top form in this movie was confirmed by mega dancer Barrie Chase, who after attending the screening stated in no uncertain terms concerning Fosse’s performance, “Bobby never danced better. Not a wrong move.”

The movie’s finale (spoiler alert) is a hilarious encounter between Betty Garrett and a platoon of Brazilian sailors, staged by Fosse as Keystone Kops comedy, in which the gorgeous-hunk Brazilians are set ablaze by a single word, “Conga!”

So well done by Fosse, seen below with the incandescent Betty Garrett, whose son Andy Parks attended the screening.

Footnote: Not to belabor but for the record: artsmeme restates its concurrence with the Verdon Fosse Legacy that Bob Fosse had no involvement — as dancer, choreographer, choreographer’s assistant, or dance-in — in White Christmas. The choreographer of that film was Robert Alton.

3 thoughts on “Bob Fosse ‘wunderbar’ in MY SISTER EILEEN at retrospective

  1. debra levine Aug 28,2018 9:06 pm

    What sources are those sources? What matters here is that the Verdon Fosse Legacy states that Fosse was not on the film. Every thing to the contrary must be proven.

  2. debra levine Aug 28,2018 9:04 pm

    It doesn’t look like his work at all. It looks like Robert Alton’s work, as it should, as he choreographed it. Alton also choreographed “Choreography,” “Mandy,” “Love, You Didn’t Do Right by Me” and more. There is nothing Fosse in this movie, and Bob Fosse was not even in Los Angeles when it was filmed. You may like to read my description of Robert Alton’s style which is on display in “Best Things.” Description here: https://artsmeme.com/2018/07/21/hollywoods-hardest-hit-on-white-christmas-1954-the-dancers/

    No one has shown evidence to the contrary and I have tons of evidence that Fosse was not involved.
    Thanks for your comment, Michael.

  3. michael schlesinger Aug 28,2018 5:25 pm

    Some sources say that Fosse worked uncredited on CHRISTMAS, and point to “The Best Things Happen While You’re Dancing,” which looks like his work. Not confirming or denying, just sayin’.

Leave a Reply